Lemon Coolers ( A famous retired Knockoff Cookie Recipe)

Saturday, March 27, 2010
Here is a old time retired knockoff, maybe some of you will remember, Lemon Coolers, changed now to lemonades changed to a cookie with icing now. One of the easier cookies to make in this knockoff series, I've been posting. Thought I would take a little trip down memory lane. My dad use to love any lemon cookies, although mom would make an Italian version home made more like soft cookies with frosting, these were one of the only "store bought cookies" he ate besides the marshmallow cookies, (oh boy he loved them as well, another future post!) Those cookies go back long ago when they cost maybe fifty cents a box, can you believe it? Back in the early 70's wow. Then researching seems to make these retired for at least 12 years or more. Amazing there are still huge fans out there hoping they bring these back. Other companies have tried to make them and never got the vanilla cookies crunch with the tart lemon flavor just right.

I absolutely love these cookies, crunchy, tart, buttery. I am sure we can't ever really recreate the memories of the past cookies, different times, different atmosphere, a whole other past life. Things have really changes. G. S.'s, would not only go door to door, they had booths set up that I can remember at schools, convention centers, we now have them in our grocery store parking lots, door to door, the boxes, marketing, prices, cookies, everything has changed since 1970 something!~ I don't remember much of the time period these were made, but that flavor is etched in your brain forever, once you've had them.

So, this may or may not be a trip down memory lane for you, but hope it gives you a warm feeling of great memories. It did for me, and the great memories I had with my dad.

Roll the while warm, then again when cool.

They hardly spread so you can put them close together

Again slicing while they are cold and firm makes the difference, that is a step you can't miss.

Slice it evenly down the center, lay the flat side down, and slice away, they are perfect half moons! So, easy.

They make quite a few cookies, sure to get everyone a bite~

Roll the dough into a long log, and refrigerate till firm, I always make mine the night before and start off in the morning after they are really firm. Easier to slice and keep their shape.

1 stick (1/2 cup) butter softened
1 cup confectionery sugar
2 teaspoons lemon extract plus 1/2 teaspoon of lemon rind finely grated
1/2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
2 cups flour
1 tablespoon cornstarch
1/4 teaspoon salt
8 tablespoons of heavy cream
more confectionery sugar for rolling the cookies in after cooked

In a large bowl, cream together the butter and confectioners’ sugar until smooth. Beat in lemon extract, vanilla extract. Add flour, cornstarch, and salt, mixing with the mixer on low speed to keep the flour from flying. Add in 8 tablespoons heavy cream and beat until mixture just comes together. Dough will be a firm ball. Roll into a smooth log on wax paper using this also to wrap to refrigerator for at least an hour or overnight.
Preheat oven to 350F. Place on ungreased cookie sheets or on parchment paper
Slice dough long way down the middle evenly to split in half. By laying them down on the flat sides to cut, you will get the half moon effect shape of these cookies. Slice at least 1/4 inch thick, they will be crunchier and buttery when cooked, if you want a softer cookie, slice thicker and cook only 8 minutes till set. Place on cookie sheets, cookies won't spread much. Bake for 10 minutes, or until edges are brown.
While still hot place confectionery sugar in a deep bowl and mix cookies into it. When cookies are cool, take a large plastic bag, add more sugar and shake cookies again to evenly coat.

Not your favorite G. S. Cookie? Try these other in the series:


Samoas  OR  Cookies or Samoas Bars



  1. Claudia I love your knock off series! I'm thinking these would melt in your mouth and look and sound yummy!

  2. wonderful step -by-step recipe!and cookies in the sunlight of spring are gorgeous!have a gooood week-end!

  3. I have never heard of these cookies but don't they look yum!

  4. Claudia, I am definitely making these. I can imagine that these slowly dissolve in your mouth.

  5. I remember these big time! My mom (or dad?) use to buy these all the time and I loved them. I'll have to give these a try.

  6. OMG these are wonderful. I love lemon flovour, delicious. Bye, have a nice Sunday

  7. You cookies series is never ending! lol

    Have a great weekend!

  8. Beautiful cookies...mmm. That's a lot you made! Now I wonder if any is coming my way. I have been very good lately, Claudia :D I should be rewarded! :P

  9. Tart and sweet and melt-in-your mouth delicious! I love them! Your knock-off series rocks.

    I have a Nikon point and shoot - it's very fussy - I don't recommend it. I can take pictures inside but only with lots of sun streaming in. If it's a cloudy day my pictures are crap.

  10. Did you make these outside? I love your pictures of the process. I haven't heard of these cookies either, but knowing you they are GOOD!

  11. I just know this buttery crunch cookie is for me - love everything about it ... Mom made one very similar and I still remember the first bite, inhaling the sugar as I bit into it ... yum

  12. I love the textures of these cookies... GREG

  13. I love lemon and can just imagine how these beautiful cookies would slowly melt on my tongue -gorgeous! More cookies please!

  14. I love lemon cookies and remember these coolers; and it is so cool that you can make them and I bet they taste way better than the commercial version!

  15. Thank you for sharing this recipe; I love these! I can tell you( and I realize this is an older blog post,lol) but they sell Lemon Coolers for $1 a box at Dollar General, they also have Citrus Coolers, an orange flavored cookie, and I love both of them.
    Thank you,


Remember to use the search option for a recipe you're looking for and thanks for all your kind words and support. We love our readers all the best Claudia