Peanut Butter Graham Brownie Recipe

Thursday, July 16, 2020
Easy as can be, you will love this recipe if you love peanut butter and graham crackers!

Here is a dessert that the kids will be asking for over and over and adults young at heart.

I have been experimenting for years with brownie mixes and made several kinds of stuffed mixes.

Starting with a mix is so versatile, but of course, you can use a homemade brownie recipe.

The favorites are my peanut butter graham brownies, oreo brownies, smore brownies and of course, I can't forget nutter butter stuffed brownie.

What can be easier than starting out with a mix and transforming it into a decadent over the top dessert?

With the added ingredients no one knew they were a mix anyway!

I love a quick and easy recipe, you can get creative too, just add your favorite cookies!

Scroll down to the printable instructions (I actually feel guilty writing this down it's so dang easy!)

These are stuffed brownie with peanut butter and graham crackers. They are in a 13 x 9 sheet pan that's metal and being serving with a metal spatula

Perfect Easy Brownies Stuffed

If you want to wow your co-workers, family, picnic party or just because you're a brownie lover,
this recipe is for you.

This easy to throw together brownie starts out with you favorite mix and transformed into a chocolate and peanut butter lovers favorite.

It's not only super easy, but you can also stuff these brownies with any kind of filled cookies you like and make it different each and every time you make them!

This is the best-doctored brownie mix recipe ever!

These are stuffed  cut brownie with peanut butter and graham crackers. They are in a 13 x 9 sheet pan that's metal and being serving with a metal spatula

Easy Ingredients to Have:

  • peanut butter, creamy or chunky
  • brownie mix any kind
  • chocolate chips or peanut butter flavored morsels
  • chocolate frosting any kind

These are stuffed brownie with peanut butter and graham crackers. They are in a 13 x 9 sheet pan that is aluminum and ready to bake


  • Don't overbake the brownies and make to package instructions
  • Use a toothpick method on the space no graham filled stuffing is to see if brownies are done
  • For peanut allergies, use a cookie butter, or sunflower butter, you can also spread with jams you prefer
  • Marshmallow also will work in this recipe with a thin chocolate bar
  • Spread with frosting while still warm
  • Use any peanut butter filled cookies if you're in a hurry or choose another kind without nuts for allergies
  • The middle may look uncooked but will set after cooling, bake to package instructions

These are stuffed brownie with peanut butter nutter butter and peanut butter chips .They are in a 13 x 9 sheet pan


Here are some delicious filling and cookies I have tried in combinations

  • Chocolate bars and coconut with graham crackers
  • Oreos and peanut butter spread on each one
  • I have used buttery style crackers and peanut butter with jelly
  • Nutter butter with nothing else on them in the batter
  • Marshmallow and chocolate bars sandwiched between the graham crackers
  • Nutella Marshmallows and chocolate graham crackers

nutella, marshmallows on top of chocolate graham crackers

Get Creative!

Starting with a mix, you can create anything you love that will bake right?

I have tried many kinds of cookies also, oreos, nutter butter, any filled kinds that are your family favorite and they all are delicious.

Combinations and spread are endless.

When I first tried these I thought since cinnamon graham crackers are my favorite combination with peanut butter, guess what I am trying next?

Any flavored graham crackers are great too, cinnamon and chocolate are going to be a winner!

this is brownie mix batter

More Recipes You May Like

Smore Stuffed Brownies

Oreo Stuffed Brownies

Nutter Butter Brownies

Homemade Brownies

These are stuffed brownie with peanut butter and graham crackers. They are in a 13 x 9 sheet pan that is aluminum and ready to bake

Pin for later

this is how to make stuffed brownies using a mix pin for later

Brownies Are A Picnic Favorite

If you're looking for a winning combination favorite, just check my suggestions.

These brownies will be a picnic and backyard cookout favorite and really are so simple to make.

The kids have a blast coming up with ideas, but I can tell you for sure these are the favorite most asked for.

If you are allergic to peanut butter try using sunflower seed butter or cookie butter!

Peanut Butter Graham Brownie Recipe

Peanut Butter Graham Brownie Recipe

Yield: 24
Author: Claudia Lamascolo
Prep time: 8 MCook time: 25 MTotal time: 33 M
These are a decadent brownie that is stuffed with a graham cracker filled with peanut butter. The brownie starts with a mix and the creations can be endless!


  • Peanut Butter Graham Brownie Recipe
  • 1 brownie mix any kind mixed to the package instructions family size that would be for a full-size brownie pan
  • graham crackers either honey or cinnamon even the chocolate ones work well!
  • peanut butter, creamy or chunky ( substitute cookie butter or sunflower butter for allergies)
  • 1 cup of milk chocolate chips, or other flavored chips you like
  • 1 can of chocolate frosting any other flavored kind
  • Optional: Peanut Butter filled cookies any brand, Oreo filled cookies any flavor, or another cookie you prefer.


  1. Mix the brownie mix to the package instructions add 1 cup chocolate chip and stir. Pour into a prepared brownie pan that has been greased.
  2. Break the graham crackers in half and spread with peanut butter making sandwiches of them.
  3. Place on top of the brownie prepared batter as shown above more if you like to fit. I used 6 sandwiches that seemed to be perfect.
  4. Bake at 350 until set and to the package instructions ( around 25 to 30 minutes). 
  5. The batter won't totally cover the crackers that are normal and will set after cooling.
  6. While still a little warm frost with canned frosting. 
  7. Sprinkle the top with crushed graham crackers nuts if using, more chocolate chips or even crushed candy bars.
brownies stuffed, cookie stuffed brownies, peanut butter and graham crackers stuffed brownies, peanut butter stuffed brownies, stuffed peanut butter brownies, doctored brownie mix
cookies, desserts, brownies, cake mix doctored, doctored brownie mix
Created using The Recipes Generator

Pin for later

pin for later stuffed brownies

Try Some Other Favorite Dessert Recipes

Irish Cream Cakemix Bars
Mallow Cup Brownies
Smoothie Candy Mock Blondie Bars
Macadamia Bars
Linzer Cookie Pistachio Raspberry BARS
Coconut 7 layer Style Cookie Bars

These are stuffed brownie with peanut butter and graham crackers. They are in a 13 x 9 sheet pan that's metal and being serving with a metal spatula

Disclosure: This recipe was originally shared in 2014. It was edited and re-published in 2020.


  1. How can I add these recipes to my Pinterest page; I don't see a link.

  2. Lynette right at the top of the first photo if you hover over the left side it says Pin in red. Click that or one other way, above the date there are boxes for facebook twitter etc. The bottom says more when you click it brings up a pinterest button click and send. thanks for asking.

  3. If all else fails @lynette here is the link


Remember to use the search option for a recipe you're looking for and thanks for all your kind words and support. We love our readers all the best Claudia